Who We ArePower Plants & FacilitiesBoard of DirectorsFinancial InfoWholesale PowerEnergy DeliveryMore
ApplyFacility MapBenefitsCo-op Students/InternshipsMilitary TransitionMore
Current HeadlinesCurrent TopicsMedia ContactsPress PacketImage GalleryNews ArchiveNewsroom SearchMore
Access My AccountPay My Bill OnlineMy Account InformationHow To Read My BillLandlord InfoMore
My HomeMy BusinessMy Account Service RequestRatesContractsHouse Moving GuidelinesMore
NE Standards CorrelationKids KornerAvailable ResourcesNPPD Energy EducatorsMore
ServicesSite Consultantssites.nppd.comNEDI OnlineMore

System Overview

COMPARISON OF COSTS BETWEEN
ELECTRIC vs. AIR MOTOR
FOR A 1 HP APPLICATION

Based on 5,000 hours/year at $0.05/kWh

* An air motor will require about 7hp of compressor capacity or 27-30cfm of air to obtain 1hp output from the air motor.

Why is Compressed Air so Inefficient?

Motor energy is converted to heat in the compression process.

  • As shown above, the energy available to do useful work is less than 20% of the compressor input energy.
  • If the air is compressed to 100 or 110 psig, by time it is cooled, dried and delivered to the point of use, the pressure may only be 85-95psi.
  • Depending on the application, the air may be regulated down, or exhausted at greater than atmospheric pressure (10-14 psig exhaust for air tools).
  • A typical air tool application may have an overall efficiency of only 12-15% efficiency and an application where the air is regulated down to 50psig prior to use would have an overall efficiency of only 7-9%.

Life Cycle Cost Analysis of a Compressor

In deciding what compressor to purchase, there may be more important factors than cost. The graph below shows a 10 year life cycle cost for a screw compressor.

@ $0.06/kwh, a single stage rotary screw compressor costs about $10,000/year per 100cfm to operate!
(electricity only, based on 8,000 hrs/yr. runtime)

When selecting a compressor, the following should be taken into consideration:

  • What is the total cost of ownership?
  • What type of controls will best suit my operation?
  • Two stage compressors will likely save money in the long run.

Plant Air Compressor Deliveries

5.0 to 5.3 cfm/hp
· H/D 2 Stage Water
Cooled Recips.

4.5 to 5.0 cfm/hp
· Multistage Centrifs.
· 2 Stage Rotary Screw
· Higher Speed 2 Stage Recips.

4.25 to 4.5 cfm/hp
· Lower Rotor Speed Single
Stage Oil Flooded Screw

4.0 to 4.25 cfm/hp
· Most Single Stage Oil
Flooded Screw

What Price is Efficiency:

Comparing a 1000cfm rated machine operating at 4 cfm/hp vs. 5.25cfm/hp, the difference would be $25,000 per year in electrical costs. (Based on 8500 hrs/yr @ $.05/kWh and $7/kW).

For additional information or assistance, contact Kelly Beiermann, Nebraska Public Power District.

Note: We encourage requests from Nebraska customers. Businesses outside of Nebraska will be directed to their utility for further information.

Source: Airometrix Mfg., Inc. 1999-2003